Epilepsy Patients Help Decode The Brain's Hidden Signals
Patients with severe epilepsy are giving scientists the chance to see the human brain in action, a view they could never get with an MRI or other high-tech tools.
By applying small jolts of electricity to the brain, they're able to wipe out a person's ability to recognize faces, to spark hallucinations, or even induce a will to persevere, as researchers reported last week.
None of this would be possible without patients like 41-year-old Nate Bennett of Santa Cruz, Calif. He's had epilepsy since he was a teenager, and it's getting worse, to the point where he worries that he'll lose his job as a restaurant manager.
In his back pocket, Bennett carries around a black leather wallet about the size of an envelope, attached to a key chain. He made it himself. His teeth have left deep scars in the leather. That's a good sign: It means he had time to prepare.
"If I'm conscious and I feel the seizure starting, I warn people around me what's going on," he says. "I lay down on the floor and I put this in my mouth. That way when I wake up, I may not have bitten my tongue."
Bennett has one or two grand mal seizures a month, sometimes in the middle of the workday. He's unable to drive and worries about having to go on disability and losing his health insurance. Medication isn't helping.
That makes Bennett a potential candidate for surgery to remove the part of his brain that's causing the seizures, and possibly cure his epilepsy.
The first step is to find out whether his seizures originate in a specific place in the brain, and if so, whether that's a part of the brain that could safely be removed.
Back in August, Bennett underwent surgery to implant electrodes in his brain at Stanford University Hospital in Palo Alto. The electrodes are designed to read his brain's electrical activity, including the electrical storms that cause his seizures.
Waking from anesthesia, Bennett was groggy but gave a visitor the thumbs-up. "I'm putting reality back together here ... gradually," he says with a smile.
A doctor tells Bennett that while he was unconscious, a surgeon implanted seven wires in his brain — two in the right hemisphere and five in the left. Each is a bit thicker than a human hair and extends about 1½ inches into his brain.
"What a party," Bennett replies wryly.
Bennett will spend a week or more in the hospital. To keep himself occupied, he's brought a bag of musical instruments and a copy of Siddhartha, by Hermann Hesse.
A few days after the electrodes were implanted, Bennett welcomed visitors into his hospital room. His head is wrapped in bandages. A thick braid of wires hangs from his left temple.
At the bedside is Dr. Josef Parvizi, an associate professor of neurology at Stanford University and Bennett's doctor. Today, Parvizi is going to send tiny jolts of electricity along the electrodes and into Bennett's brain.
Essentially, he's exploring Bennett's brain, neuron by neuron.
To be clear, this is completely painless. But very strange things happen when you stimulate the brain this way.
One of Bennett's electrodes is located in the dorsal anterior cingulate, a part of the brain associated with automatic speech, like saying "ouch" or "whoa." Parvizi sends a small 4-milliamp jolt there.
Bennett suddenly lurches forward.
"I became unable to speak," he tells Parvizi. "I was going to say 'jinx.' I, I, I ... I started stuttering. I couldn't get the words out."
The notion that epilepsy offers a window into the brain has a long history.
In the 19th century, English neurologist John Hughlings Jackson observed an epileptic seizure that seemed to travel from one part of his patient's body to another.
To Jackson, this revealed that the disease was affecting parts of the brain in succession, each with a corresponding effect on the body. This phenomenon is still called the Jacksonian March.
"Epilepsy gave us our first clue that parts of the brain are responsible for parts of the body, or for different senses," says Dr. Edward Chang, a neurologist and neurosurgeon at the University of California, San Francisco, whose work with epilepsy patients has led to key findings about how humans process speech.
In the 1960s, a Canadian epilepsy specialist named Wilder Penfield found that by stimulating certain parts of the brain, he could make people move their hands involuntarily, or report a smell of burning leather.
Parvizi is one of a handful of neuroscientists who have picked up Penfield's torch, showing that brain regions correspond not just to body parts or senses, but to emotions.
In a video of an experiment with another epilepsy patient, Parvizi sends a small jolt of electricity to a part of the brain called the anterior midcingulate cortex, a part of the brain located about 2 inches behind the bridge of the nose.
The patient's heart begins to race. Parvizi asks him to describe how he feels.
"I started getting this feeling like I was driving into a storm," the man says. "As if one of the tires was half flat, and you're only halfway there. There's no way to turn around and go back. You have to keep going forward."
Parvizi asks, "Was this negative or was it positive?"
This is the part that's most interesting to Parvizi and his colleagues, because while the patient clearly feels a sense of danger, he feels something else, too: a determination to get through it.
"It was more of positive thing," the patient says. "Like, 'Push harder, push harder to get through this.' "
When the anterior midcingulate cortex is stimulated, Parvizi says, patients "have the will to go towards the storm" and fight, "rather than giving up, being scared, depressed and running back."
This study, which was published last week in the journal Neuron, lines up with other research on the area of the brain known as the "salience network," says coauthor Dr. Michael Greicius, an assistant professor of neurology at Stanford University.
"Over the last 20 years or so we've started to get this sense for a network that's constantly scanning the environment and manipulating the internal environment," Greicius says. It does that by adjusting heart rate and blood pressure, reducing blood flow from the gut, and "generally shifting [the body's] resources from what's less urgent to the task at hand."
"That's the beauty of evolution, right?" says Parvizi. "If you really are going to go through difficulty, you'd better have higher blood pressure so your muscles can get the blood and run or fight."
This illustrates the great debt that neuroscience owes to patients like Nate Bennett, says Dr. Orrin Devinsky, a professor of neurology at NYU's School of Medicine.
It is one thing, Devinsky says, to study the brain through MRI scans or animal models. It's another thing to zap a specific part of the brain and be able to ask the patient to describe what happens.
"We only use these electrodes if there's a clinical application," says Devinsky, "but once they're in, we have this incredible scientific opportunity."
Brain stimulation is already used to treat certain disorders, including Parkinson's disease and in experimental settings, for depression. Devinsky says Parvizi's findings might hint at future therapies.
But for now, the goal is to solve the problem of Bennett's epilepsy, starting by figuring out where his seizures are coming from.
Back at the hospital in August, Parvizi flips a switch and a jolt of electricity enters Bennett's brain.
"I feel a change," warns Bennett. "I might have a seizure."
Bennett's face hardens. His eyes fix on some invisible spot across the room. He's having a seizure. This is a good thing. The electrodes implanted in his brain have recorded exactly where it came from.
But further testing reveals that there is not just one source of Bennett's seizures, or even two. Instead, they come from points spread out across his brain. So he's not a candidate for surgery to stop the seizures.
This was disappointing, Bennett says. But being part of a scientific experiment was a silver lining.
"For me, I'd like to see something positive come out of it all, even if it's for somebody else. You know?" he says, after the electrodes were removed and he was back at work.
And his exploration isn't over, Bennett says. A new epilepsy device called the NeuroPace — kind of like a pacemaker for the brain — recently got FDA premarket approval.
Pretty soon he'll start looking into that.
STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:
On a Monday, it's MORNING EDITION from NPR News. Good morning, I'm Steve Inskeep.
DAVID GREENE, HOST:
And I'm David Greene.
Today in Your Health: A rare glimpse into the human brain. Neuroscientists are studying some patients with severe epilepsy to see if surgery might cure their seizures. The procedure has been an opportunity to see the brain in action while awake. And as we're about to hear, this is leading to some remarkable findings.
Amy Standen from member station KQED in San Francisco has the story.
AMY STANDEN, BYLINE: Nate Bennett has been having seizures since he was a teenager. But he's 41 now and they've gotten much worse. If one were to strike right now, he told me, he'd get ready for it.
NATE BENNETT: I would begin to get this feeling.
STANDEN: People with epilepsy call it an aura, this pre-seizure feeling.
BENNETT: I would tell you I'm beginning having a seizure, I would find a spot on the floor.
STANDEN: Alone, ideally. He says he doesn't want to scare people.
BENNETT: And then I would get my custom wallet out.
STANDEN: He pulls it out to show me.
BENNETT: Yup, this wallet that I've designed, piece of Velcro - you see it's full of bite marks.
STANDEN: The wallet is black leather, about the size of an envelope. His teeth have left gray scars along the spine.
BENNETT: I lay down on the floor. I put this in my mouth and that way, when I wake up from the seizure, I may not have bitten my tongue.
STANDEN: Nate's seizures have progressed to the point where he worries about losing his job. Medication isn't helping. This makes him a candidate for surgery. But the first step is to find out whether Nate's seizures originate in a specific place. And if so, whether that's a part of the brain that could safely be removed, which brings Nate to Stanford Hospital.
Finding the source of Nate's epilepsy involves a procedure in which electrodes are surgically implanted into his brain.
BENNETT: Hey, there.
UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN: Great. How are you?
STANDEN: I visit him as he's waking from anesthesia. He's groggy, but he gives me a thumbs up.
BENNETT: I'm putting reality back together here, gradually.
STANDEN: Nate asks a doctor how the surgery went.
BENNETT: I've got five or six electrodes at this point.
UNIDENTIFIED MAN #1: You've got seven electrodes - two on the right and then five on the left.
BENNETT: Wow, what a party.
STANDEN: Each of those is actually a string of electrodes, embedded along plastic wires just a little thicker than a human hair. Nate will spend a week in the hospital with these electrodes implanted in his brain. When he has his next seizure, they should be able to track where it's coming from. But the electrodes can do something else too. They can show us things about the brain that have implications well beyond epilepsy.
A few days after the electrodes have been implanted, I go back to see Nate at the hospital. His head is wrapped in bandages. A thick braid of wires hangs from his left temple.
JOSEF PARVIZI: Take a deep breath, and just relax.
STANDEN: At the bedside is Josef Parvizi, Nate's doctor.
PARVIZI: So let's see.
STANDEN: Parvizi is an epilepsy specialist at Stanford University Medical Center and a brain researcher. And today, he's going to send tiny jolts of electricity along the electrodes and into Nate's brain.
STANDEN: Essentially, he's exploring Nate's brain, neuron by neuron.
PARVIZI: One, two, three...
STANDEN: To be clear, this is completely painless. But very strange things happen when you stimulate the brain this way.
PARVIZI: I want you to tell us if you feel anything that resembles your seizures. OK?
STANDEN: One of Nate's electrodes is located in a part of the brain associated, among other things, with automatic speech - like saying: ouch or whoa. Parvizi sends a small jolt there.
BENNETT: I- I, yup, change.
STANDEN: Nate's suddenly lurched forward.
BENNETT: I became unable to speak and I was going to say jinx. I-I-I-I started stuttering. I couldn't get the words out.
STANDEN: Scientists have been doing this kind of brain stimulation on people with epilepsy since the 1960s. That's when a Canadian neurosurgeon named Wilder Penfield found that by stimulating certain parts of the brain, he could make people move their hands involuntarily or report a smell of burning leather. In many ways, this was the birth of modern brain mapping; the idea that specific functions can be traced back to specific brain areas.
Parvizi is one of a handful of neuroscientists who have picked up Penfield's torch. Last week, the journal Neuron published a paper describing some of this work, not with Nate but with two other patients.
(SOUNDBITE OF A VIDEO)
PARVIZI: Let me know what you feel.
UNIDENTIFIED MAN #2: OK.
STANDEN: In the video released with the paper, a man sits in bed. Like Nate, this man has severe epilepsy. He's in the hospital so to find the source of his seizures. Parvizi sends a small jolt of electricity to a part of the brain called the anterior cingulate. The patient's heart began to race.
(SOUNDBITE OF A VIDEO)
UNIDENTIFIED MAN #2: My chest and respiratory system started getting kind of shaky.
PARVIZI: Really? OK.
STANDEN: He sort of flutters his hands, clutching his chest, to demonstrate.
(SOUNDBITE OF A VIDEO)
PARVIZI: Did you feel any changes in emotion or mood?
STANDEN: Yes, the man nods. And then he tries to explain the weird feeling he had, when this part of his brain was stimulated.
(SOUNDBITE OF A VIDEO)
UNIDENTIFIED MAN #2: I started getting this feeling like I was driving into a storm.
STANDEN: As if he was driving into a storm. And the car he was driving, it had a flat.
(SOUNDBITE OF A VIDEO)
UNIDENTIFIED MAN #2: Like one of the tires was half flat and you're only half way there. And you had no other way to turn around and go back, you had to keep going forward.
STANDEN: Like he was in danger and might not make it. He pounds his chest, for emphasis.
(SOUNDBITE OF A VIDEO)
UNIDENTIFIED MAN #2: Am I going to get through this? Am I going to get through this?
PARVIZI: Was it negative, or was it positive?
STANDEN: Now this is the part that's most interesting to Parvizi and his co-authors. Because while the patient clearly feels a sense of danger, he feels something else, too - a determination to get through it, to survive.
(SOUNDBITE OF A VIDEO)
UNIDENTIFIED MAN #2: It was more of a positive type thing of push harder, push harder, push harder to try to get through this.
PARVIZI: Will to persevere.
STANDEN: That's what the paper in Neuron is called, based on these reports from two patients, "The Will to Persevere."
PARVIZI: They have the will to go towards the storm and fight it rather than giving up, being scared, depressed and running back.
STANDEN: And it makes perfect sense, says Parvizi, that this will to survive, would be coupled with a pounding heart.
PARVIZI: That's the beauty of evolution, right? If you really are going to go through difficulty, you'd better have a higher blood pressure so your muscles can get the blood and run or fight, or whatever.
STANDEN: And that this hard-wired urge might even feel good.
(SOUNDBITE OF A VIDEO)
PARVIZI: Is this unpleasant?
UNIDENTIFIED MAN #2: I don't find it bad at all.
STANDEN: Part of what's remarkable here, is access, says Orrin Devinsky, a professor of neurology at NYU's Langone School of Medicine.
It is one thing to study the brain through MRI scans, another thing entirely to literally zap a specific part of the brain and then ask the patient to describe what happens. Devinsky calls epilepsy patients like Nate Bennett heroes of neuroscience.
ORRIN DEVINSKY: A lot of things that the brain does, we can look at with these patients who have been incredibly generous.
STANDEN: And there are clues in this work that hint at future treatments. Brain stimulation is already used to treat certain disorders, including Parkinson's disease and in experimental settings, depression. Maybe the part Parvizi's stimulating could be another target.
DEVINSKY: There are patients I take care of who have injured their frontal lobes and because of that, their overall spontaneity, their will to do things...
STANDEN: Is just gone, he says.
DEVINSKY: For people like that, stimulation of this area could potentially be a very promising treatment.
(SOUNDBITE OF MACHINERY)
STANDEN: For now, back at the hospital, the goal is to solve the problem of Nate's epilepsy, starting by figuring out where his seizures are coming from.
PARVIZI: And tell me if you notice any change.
BENNETT: Yeah, there is a change.
PARVIZI: Open your eyes.
BENNETT: And I might have a seizure.
STANDEN: Nate's face hardens. His eyes fix on some invisible spot across the room. He's having a seizure. This is a good thing. The electrodes implanted in his brain have recorded exactly where it came from.
(SOUNDBITE OF GROAN)
UNIDENTIFIED MAN #3: It's very clammy. Very clammy.
STANDEN: A doctor injects Nate with a dose of Atavan to stop the seizure. A nurse ushers me out of the room.
(SOUNDBITE OF BEEPING)
PARVIZI: You're OK. You're OK.
STANDEN: A couple weeks later, I call Nate at home. The electrodes have been removed and he's back at work.
BENNETT: My first day back was Friday of last week.
STANDEN: He says in the end, his doctors decided not to go with the surgery. The source of his seizures is too spread out across his brain. This was disappointing, he says. But being part of scientific experiments, that was a silver lining.
BENNETT: For me, I'd like to see something positive come out of it all, even if it's for somebody else.
STANDEN: And his story is not over, he says. A new epilepsy device called the Neuropace - kind of like a pacemaker for the brain - recently got FDA approval. Pretty soon, he'll start looking into that.
For NPR News, I'm Amy Standen.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
GREENE: And you're listening to MORNING EDITION from NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.